Skip to content
Why Is Pure Positive Training Failing to Stop My Doberman’s Bad Habits?
Pure positive training often fails high-drive Dobermans when bad habits are inherently rewarding. If your Dobie barks and the mailman walks away, the behavior becomes self-rewarding. Fixing this requires all four quadrants of balanced dog training, including strict commands and fair boundaries.
The Trainer Brain Never Shuts Off
Before dedicating all my time to founding Willow’s Wish Doberman Rescue and DoberMerch Designs, I spent over 15 years working with clients as a dog trainer right here in Ontario. Even as I hang up that hat, the trainer brain never goes away.
Lately, I’ve been watching the “pure positive” or “fear-free” movement take over, and while they got some things right, they completely miss the mark on others. Here is what they got right: a behavior is absolutely more likely to reoccur if it’s rewarded. Give your Dobie a high-value treat when they sit, and they will sit.
But notice I use the word command, not cue. A high-drive working breed needs to be commanded. If you treat obedience like a polite suggestion or a “cue,” a Doberman will quickly become the one commanding you.
The Mailman Problem: When Bad Behavior is the Reward
Where the pure positive approach falls apart is when you are trying to stop an unwanted behavior that is inherently rewarding.
Take Major, the very first Doberman I ever met back in the late 80s. Every day, the mail carrier dropped letters through the slot, and Major went absolutely ballistic. He would tear through bills and flyers like his safety depended on it. Why? Because from Major’s perspective, this human was disrespecting his territory daily. His internal loop was simple: “Intruder approaches. I protect the house. Threat retreats. Mission completed.”
The act of barking and “chasing the threat away” was the reward itself. If that mail carrier had ever needed to deliver a parcel, there is a very real chance he could have been seriously injured. You cannot fix a self-rewarding, genetic behavior loop with a pocket full of hot dogs.
Major never received the training he needed. But during my years working with clients, I fixed this exact issue by teaching a bomb-proof Place command. I used to jokingly tell owners their Dobie wasn’t allowed to break Place even if the house was burning down. To enforce a boundary that strict against a dog’s natural drive, you need the whole training table.
You cannot fix a self-rewarding, genetic behavior loop with a pocket full of hot dogs.
The Full Operant Conditioning Table
To stop these behaviors, you need all four quadrants, not just positive reinforcement.
Unapologetic Leadership
High-drive dogs crave clarity, leadership, and a handler who isn’t afraid to set rules. If you’re the kind of owner who embraces the gritty reality of balanced training, our Doberman AF Hooded Sweatshirt was made for you. With its unapologetic chest hit and the hardcore, vintage-style chained Dobie on the back, it’s a statement piece for the owner who knows you can’t bribe genetics. Wear it proudly on your local trails, knowing your purchase directly funds the vetting and balanced rehabilitation of heavy-hitting rescue dogs at Willow’s Wish Doberman Rescue.
Discover more from DoberMerchDesigns
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
